How to set boundaries
LISTEN IN APPLE PODCASTS | LISTEN IN SPOTIFY | LISTEN IN STITCHER
Perfectionism and Time Management: The Labels That Are Secretly Running Your Schedule
What if the biggest thing sabotaging your time isn’t your planner, your workload, or your lack of discipline — but the story you tell yourself about who you are?
In this episode, we’re talking about perfectionism and time management — and how identity labels like perfectionist, people pleaser, hard worker, multitasker, Type A, Type B, and even your personality test results might be shaping your schedule more than you realize.
Because here’s the truth:
The story you tell about who you are becomes the schedule you live.
If you believe you’re a perfectionist, you’ll delay finishing.
If you believe you’re a people pleaser, you’ll overcommit.
If you believe you’re Type A, you’ll glorify busy.
If you believe you’re Type B, you’ll excuse chaos.
And over time, those identities stop being descriptors and start becoming excuses.
In this episode, we’re peeling off the labels and updating the story so your time reflects who you’re becoming — not who you used to be.
Key Takeaways
- Why perfectionism and time management are deeply connected
- How identity labels form and why they once worked
- The hidden time cost of being a “hard worker”
- How multitasking creates attention residue and reduces productivity
- Why Type A and Type B are stress patterns, not personality brands
- How personality tests can become permission slips for bad habits
- One simple way to interrupt the label you’ve been hiding behind
Where These Labels Come From
Most of these identities didn’t appear out of thin air.
They were adaptive strategies.
At some point, they helped you.
Maybe in childhood you were praised for achievement — so you became the perfectionist.
Maybe following the rules made you feel safe — so you became the rule follower.
Maybe working hard got you promoted — so you doubled down.
Maybe keeping the peace meant being loved — so you became the people pleaser.
These weren’t flaws.
They were strategies.
But adaptive strategies are not lifelong contracts.
What protected you at eight may be exhausting you at thirty-eight.
What got you promoted at twenty-five may be burning you out at forty-five.
Just because it worked once doesn’t mean it still serves you.
Perfectionism and Time Management
Let’s start with the big one.
Perfectionism often masquerades as excellence, but it’s usually indecision dressed up as high standards.
Perfectionism shows up in your time as:
- Delayed starts
- Endless revisions
- Overthinking
- Struggling to decide when something is “done”
- Tiny improvements at massive emotional cost
Perfectionists don’t struggle with quality.
They struggle with stopping.
And when you don’t know when to stop, projects stretch longer than necessary and your schedule fills with unnecessary pressure.
The shift:
Define what “done” means before you start — and honor a hard stop time.
Rule Follower
Rule followers thrive in structure — until they don’t.
When a productivity system doesn’t work exactly as taught, rule followers often blame themselves instead of adapting the system.
Not every rule is a good rule.
And no one is sending you to the principal’s office for tweaking a method to fit your life.
The shift:
Respect structure, but trust yourself to adapt it.
Type A and Type B
Type A and Type B were originally coined by cardiologists studying stress patterns and heart disease.
They were never meant to be personality brands.
Type A and Time Management
Type A tendencies often show up as:
- Urgency addiction
- Back-to-back scheduling
- Glorifying exhaustion
- Hoarding responsibility
- Struggling to delegate
Type A personalities often say:
“I can’t take vacation. Everything would fall apart.”
If everything falls apart when you leave, that’s not leadership — that’s a system problem.
When you refuse to delegate, you become the bottleneck.
And over time, your schedule collapses under its own weight.
The shift:
Build margin. Delegate. Trust others to learn.
Type B and Time Management
Type B tendencies often show up as:
- Underestimating how long things take
- Avoiding structure
- Running late
- Waiting for motivation
Being relaxed does not mean being unreliable.
Chronic chaos is not a personality trait — it’s a pattern.
If you’re always late, it’s not personality. It’s math.
The shift:
Track how long things actually take and build in buffer time.
People Pleaser
People pleasing often hides behind kindness.
But underneath, it’s usually:
- Fear of disappointing others
- Discomfort with conflict
- Outsourcing your worth to approval
And here’s the time cost:
You say yes before checking your calendar.
You rearrange priorities for last-minute requests.
You overcommit — and then feel resentful.
Every time you say yes when you mean no, you donate your time to someone else’s goals.
The shift:
Pause. Say “Let me check my schedule.”
Practice one clean no this week.
Hard Worker
Hard work is honorable.
But when hard work becomes your identity, it can quietly sabotage your time.
Many high achievers were told:
“Keep your head down. Work hard. People will notice.”
That advice creates invisible women.
Hard workers often:
- Overdeliver quietly
- Refuse to delegate
- Harbor resentment toward those they won’t train
- Believe work is supposed to feel uncomfortable
Research shows that working more hours does not equal more productivity. The law of diminishing returns kicks in, and most people only accomplish about three hours of deep, focused work in a typical eight-hour day.
When you stretch your day to ten or twelve hours, you don’t double productivity. You double fatigue.
The shift:
Work strategically. Delegate. Allow ease.
Multitasking and Attention Residue
Multitasking feels productive.
But research on switching costs and attention residue shows that every time you switch from responding to an email to working on a report, part of your brain lingers on the previous task.
Your attention doesn’t instantly transfer.
It lingers.
That mental reconfiguration slows you down and increases errors.
Researchers estimate that frequent switching can eat up as much as 40% of your productive time.
Multitasking creates the illusion of productivity while quietly draining effectiveness.
The shift:
Single-task for 25 minutes.
One tab. One task. Phone out of reach.
And when you catch yourself juggling tasks, remember:
Slow is smooth. Smooth is fast.
Personality Tests Are Tools — Not Permission Slips
Personality assessments can be incredibly helpful.
But they are not excuses.
Saying “I’m an Enneagram 9” doesn’t excuse avoiding hard conversations.
Saying “I’m an ENTJ” doesn’t excuse taking over everything.
Saying “I’m a 3” doesn’t excuse overfilling your calendar.
Self-awareness without self-leadership becomes self-justification.
And self-justification keeps your schedule exactly the same.
Personality results are data.
They are meant to inform growth — not limit it.
Your Next Step
Before jumping into action, pause.
Let this sink in.
Notice which label made you uncomfortable.
That’s usually the one worth exploring.
Then choose one identity you’ve been hiding behind.
Just one.
And interrupt it this week.
Delegate one thing.
Leave one block of margin.
Say one clean no.
Arrive ten minutes early.
Single-task for ten minutes.
Prove to yourself that the label is not in charge.
You are.
Episode Links and Resources
- Apply for a free time management coaching session: freetimecall.com
Related Episodes
- Episode 238 – Simple, Intentional, and Imperfect: How to Declutter Your Home, Mind, and Schedule with Sarah Horgan
- Episode 271 – The Real Reason You Think You’re Bad at Time Management
- Episode 241 – From Overthinking to Taking Action: How to Break Free from Analysis Paralysis
If this episode resonated with you, share it with a friend who might need it too.
And remember:
The story you tell about who you are becomes the schedule you live.
It’s about time you told a new one.
Be the first to comment